Netizens criticize after fromis_9 beat Nayeon on ‘M Countdown’ today
Today M Countdown’s winner points
#1 fromis_9 (full score on digital and physical)
#2 Nayeon (full score on live votes)
1. On Melon, Nayeon is 4 and fromis_9 is 120, but how did fromis_9 get the full digital score?
2. It’s embarrassing, it’s ridiculous
3. Nayeon’s song is so good…. I’ve never heard of fromis_9 before ㅜㅜ
4. Nayeon didn’t get 1st place..?? It’s a bit shocking
5. Well, they’re even proud after robbing another singer’s 1st place
6. These fans are outlawing in the music industry, right?
7. I’ve never heard of fromis_9’s songs
8. Crazy.. Nayeon should win 1st place
9. I feel sorry for Nayeon who lost 1st place
10. But even Nayeon’s physical sales are higher
Original post (1)
Shameful.
NAYEON ‘POP!’ – 7PM KST:
#2 VIBE
#2 Bugs
#3 Genie
#3 MelOn
#6 FLO
Fromis_9 ‘Stay This Way’ – 7PM KST:
#50 VIBE
#23 Bugs
#123 Genie
OUT of MelOn
OUT of FLO
Mcountdown use gaon downloads not charting you idiot
Fromis flop
Nayeon robbed
There is nothing wrong with the music show wins if we just based on the number.
Formis_9 ranked higher in both digital and physical this week on Gaon Chart.
The reason why Formis_9 ranked higher is because of the stupid bugs chart download.
Removed that chart seriously.
They ranked higher doing what’s known as ‘Talda’ (tal from taltwi/withdraw, da from daunrodeu/download) it’s a method of exploiting a loophole on the Bugs chart to download, delete and re-buy and download the same song again. It’s not supposed to be possible. Bugs limits it’s DL’s per ID to avoid chart manipulation as does every chart in Korea. Much like with Billboard charts and per-user purchase limit is enforced to prevent this kind of fan manipulation.
But certain fandoms, namely Flover’s and Danity’s use it, you can see in the link below Korean’s were exposing them last night for it, before M Countdown even aired.
It’s not an issue with Bugs per se, as Fromis 9 aren’t even doing good on Bugs lol. It’s a issue with Bugs having this loophole which allows users to buy more than the limit and thus fans use funds to have a few users mass buy downloads and manipulate the charts with fraudulent numbers.
https://theqoo.net/square/2509645677
Check this out too, other fandoms have begun doing it. It’s effectively Sajaegi only done by fans.
https://twitter.com/dsunbaenim07/status/1545004010381316096
https://theqoo.net/square/2509645677
Could you translate this article pls
The way Nayeon keeps getting blocked for the most bizarre reasons?? None of it makes sense at this point…
She flops. Make sense
if they switched the digital score, nayeon could’ve won by 13 points
Its crazy that Nayeon never got the win. She a member of top idol, album sales is massive, big success on BB and top 2 on melon. How is that not enough?